Wilmington, July 7 EST: The $7.4 billion offer from Gold Reserve’s Dalinar Energy to acquire Citgo’s parent, PDV Holding, has hit a wall of skepticism from some of the oil company’s largest creditors. With a courtroom deadline looming and competing bids still in the mix, the deal’s path to approval is anything but assured.
Bondholders Say They’re Left Out — and They’re Not Wrong
Creditors holding Venezuela’s defaulted 2020 bond—which is backed by Citgo shares—are leading a wave of objections ahead of a July 9 filing deadline. Their beef is simple: Dalinar’s bid ignores them.
In corporate terms, this is like buying a house and skipping the lien on the deed. The creditors say they can’t be pushed aside because U.S. courts haven’t yet ruled on the bond’s enforceability. Until they are paid or their claims are resolved, they argue, any transfer of Citgo equity is legally shaky.
The irony? Their argument isn’t speculative—it’s rooted in long-running litigation in New York’s Southern District, where courts are still weighing whether those bond claims are valid. If the court sides with the bondholders, Dalinar’s clean acquisition becomes a legal dead-end.
The Bidding War Isn’t Just About the Price Tag
Dalinar’s bid was selected by a Delaware court officer late last week. But price alone isn’t the whole story here. A Vitol-led group offered more than $10 billion, combining cash, credit for existing claims, and, critically, a built-in resolution for the bondholders. Another player, Black Lion Capital, came in with a straightforward $8 billion cash bid. Dalinar, by contrast, offered $7.38 to $7.4 billion, with no answer for the most litigious creditors in the room.
These aren’t abstract figures. The court-supervised auction is meant to pay down $19 billion in claims tied to Venezuela’s expropriations and bond defaults. The more creditors a bid can appease, the cleaner the sale.
But several bidders have flagged something deeper than dollar figures: a lack of transparency in how the court’s officer picked the winner. No one quite knows the weighting behind the decision—was it cash upfront? Claim coverage? Political risk? In boardroom terms, that’s like losing a contract and never hearing why.
Legal Hurdles, Regulatory Minefields
There’s still a long way between recommendation and execution. The courtroom hearing is set for August 18, where Judge Leonard Stark will decide whether Dalinar’s deal gets the green light—or if someone else walks away with Citgo.
Even if the court signs off, the U.S. government still holds veto power. Any sale will need the blessing of OFAC, the Treasury Department, and possibly CFIUS, given the geopolitical sensitivity of selling a major U.S. refiner with Venezuelan ties.
In short, this deal lives in the same regulatory pressure cooker that’s sidelined cross-border M&A for years.
The Broader Picture: Politics, Energy, and a Stalled Petrostate
Citgo is the last profitable piece of Venezuela’s battered oil empire, and everyone knows it. That’s why so many bidders are willing to jump through regulatory hoops and court fights. But the prize comes with complications.
For Dalinar, getting a recommendation from the court officer looked like a win. But if its bid can’t withstand legal scrutiny—or if a richer, cleaner offer is on the table—the court may step back. Think of it less like a typical M&A close and more like a distressed asset sale with creditors circling and judges holding the pen.
Between the politics, the lawsuits, and the creditors, this isn’t just a matter of price—it’s a matter of who can thread the needle fastest and cleanest.
Next Stop: Courtroom Chess
With objections due July 9, and the main hearing on August 18, expect a flurry of legal filings in the coming weeks. The central question remains: will the court favor a higher bid that settles more claims, or stick with Dalinar’s lower, narrower path?
No matter how it shakes out, Citgo’s sale is turning into a masterclass in how sovereign defaults, U.S. sanctions, and court-appointed auctions collide—with billions hanging in the balance.
New Jersey Times Is Your Source: The Latest In Politics, Entertainment, Business, Breaking News, And Other News. Please Follow Us On Facebook, Instagram, And Twitter To Receive Instantaneous Updates. Also Do Checkout Our Telegram Channel @Njtdotcom For Latest Updates.
A Wall Street veteran turned investigative journalist, Marcus brings over two decades of financial insight into boardrooms, IPOs, corporate chess games, and economic undercurrents. Known for asking uncomfortable questions in comfortable suits.
