Maggie Thurmon’s “Which Time?” TikTok Sends Benson Boone Fans Into Frenzy
A deleted TikTok, a sharp one-liner, and a flood of speculation inside Maggie Thurmon and Benson Boone’s viral breakup moment.
Los Angeles, October 15 EST: The breakup drama between Maggie Thurmon and Benson Boone just took a messy, very 2025 turn one that TikTok didn’t miss for a second. Over the weekend, Thurmon quietly posted (and just as quickly deleted) a TikTok that had fans double-taking. The sound asked, “Remember how it felt when he cheated on you, though?” and Thurmon, deadpan and deliberate, mouthed back: “Which time?”
Cue chaos, Within hours, her comments section was a frenzy of disbelief and sympathy emojis. When one fan joked, “If Benson cheated, I will turn this car right around,” Thurmon shot back with, “Put your blinker on, babe.” It was short, savage, and, for many, confirmation that something had gone very wrong. As Cosmopolitan put it, the now-deleted video landed like “a wink and a warning.” And given that Boone’s name has been buzzing across both FYPs and Spotify playlists, the internet was bound to notice.
From Couple Goals To Quiet Unfollows
Their breakup first hit the news cycle in September when TMZ confirmed what fans had already clocked: unfollows, archived posts, and the sudden disappearance of their couple content. They’d been together roughly three years, with Thurmon a dancer and influencer appearing in Boone’s early music videos and often joining him on tour.
Boone himself gave only a vague nod to the situation at a Nashville show on September 9. Between songs, he told the crowd, “Sometimes people leave your life… It sucks to be sad about it.” It wasn’t an admission, but it sounded a lot like heartbreak in real time.
Since then, he’s stayed publicly silent. No statements, no shade, no cryptic reposts. And that silence in an era where most celebrities subtweet their feelings in under an hour has only made the speculation louder.
Maggie’s Soft Launch Of Heartbreak
Thurmon, meanwhile, has handled the fallout with the kind of poise (and occasional passive-aggression) that social media eats up. Late last month, she dropped a “girls’ night” get-ready video, her first TikTok since the split. The tone was easy, fun, deliberately unbothered.
Then, on her book-focused Instagram account, she went quieter opening up about feeling “sad” and “overthinking,” admitting she was spending time at her parents’ place in Georgia. Fans read it as her soft-launch era of healing: no dramatic confessionals, just gentle honesty wrapped in good lighting.
That said, her latest post the “Which time?” TikTok snapped that calm wide open.
Why Fans Can’t Look Away
There’s something uniquely 2025 about this breakup. Both Thurmon and Boone built their followings on authenticity he through heartfelt ballads like “Beautiful Things,” she through candid, dance-filled glimpses into their shared life. When that image fractures, fans don’t just consume it; they participate in it.
And let’s be honest: cheating rumors hit differently when your ex writes hit singles about devotion. Boone’s catalog practically begs for lyrical rereads. TikTok’s already full of users dissecting lines from “Slow It Down” and “Cry,” searching for clues.
Still, the record shows: no confirmation, no receipts. Thurmon’s TikTok may have implied infidelity, but neither she nor Boone has offered specifics names, timelines, anything. For now, it’s subtext and speculation.
The Bigger Picture
What’s playing out between these two isn’t just celebrity gossip; it’s the collision of fame, fandom, and the TikTok feedback loop. Thurmon knows exactly how to speak the language of her audience a one-liner here, a deleted video there, each post a breadcrumb. Boone, by contrast, seems to be leaning into restraint, letting mystery (and maybe pity) do the work.
The result? A modern-day breakup PR masterclass unfolding in real time.
For now, fans are split between heartbreak and detective work, waiting for either Boone to speak up or Thurmon to drop another digital bombshell. And until someone does, TikTok will keep replaying that fateful question: “Which time?”
New Jersey Times Is Your Source: The Latest In Politics, Entertainment, Business, Breaking News, And Other News. Please Follow Us On Facebook, Instagram, And Twitter To Receive Instantaneous Updates. Also Do Checkout Our Telegram Channel @Njtdotcom For Latest Updates.
A bi-coastal pop culture critic and former indie screenwriter, Gia covers Hollywood, streaming wars, and subculture shifts with razor wit and Gen Z intuition. If it’s going viral, she already knew about it.
