Newtown Square, May 15: Rory McIlroy said one word when they asked him how the day went. It rhymes with “hit.” He didn’t say it quietly either. He just put it out there in front of the cameras and the recorders and the reporters scribbling in notebooks and let it breathe. Nobody in that press tent disagreed with him.
This was the PGA Championship 2026. This was supposed to be different.
Four weeks ago McIlroy was standing in the Butler Cabin pulling on a green jacket for the second straight year. The greatest stretch of his career. The career Grand Slam complete. The whole sport had just spent the better part of a decade waiting for him to win the Masters and when he finally did it twice back to back it felt like the beginning of something rather than the end. He came into this week at Aronimink Golf Club in Newtown Square, Pennsylvania as the man the tournament was being built around in the press, the betting markets, the television packages. The story of the PGA Championship 2026 was supposed to run through him.
Instead he shot 74 and said a bad word into a microphone.
Nine fairways missed. Four bogeys in a row at the finish. Seven shots back of the lead before the sun went down on Day 1. His very first tee shot of the week on the 10th hole, where he started leaked so far right into the rough that he couldn’t do anything with it except punch it 70 yards forward and accept the bogey. He got himself back to even par somehow, clawed and scrambled his way to something respectable with four holes left, and then fell completely apart on the way home. Bogey, bogey, bogey, bogey. Done.
“I got on that bogey train at the end,” he said afterward. He had this look on his face like a man replaying something he can’t fix. “I honestly thought I’d figured it out.”
He had not figured it out. The driver was the whole problem. It kept going right. He’d try to correct it, overdo the correction, watch it go left. Back and forth all day while Aronimink sat there and collected his mistakes like it was getting paid to do it. “I pride myself on driving the ball well,” he said. “That’s pretty frustrating.” Then he was done talking and walked away and the math was still sitting there on the leaderboard being ugly.
Last man to shoot 74 in the opening round of the PGA Championship and still win the thing was Payne Stewart in 1989. People kept bringing that up Thursday afternoon the way you bring up a long-shot statistic when you’re trying to be kind.
This Golf Course Had a Few Things to Say
Before any of the McIlroy conversation, before the leaderboard started making sense, Aronimink itself needed to be talked about because it spent Thursday completely dismantling the narrative that had been building all week.
The narrative was basically this: the course is too easy. Old Donald Ross design, recently touched up by Gil Hanse, fairways wide enough to land a small aircraft on, rough that looked manageable in the practice rounds, no water to speak of, no trees crowding the landing areas. Players were walking around early in the week with this looseness about them, this vibe that scores were going to go low and stay low. McIlroy said publicly that he might just hit driver on every single hole because thinking off the tee at Aronimink felt unnecessary. A few others nodded along to that idea.
The golf course spent Thursday making everyone who said that look a little foolish.
Wind arrived with the first groups and never left. The rough that seemed harmless in practice grabbed approach angles and killed them. Pins were tucked in places that made hitting the green feel like one thing and actually having a makeable putt feel like something else entirely. Eleven holes played over par. The low score in the morning wave was 67. Nobody ran away with anything. More than fifty players finished within three shots of the lead by late afternoon, which sounds like low scoring until you realize three shots off the lead meant 6-under through the day’s play and the actual lead was only 3-under.
Xander Schauffele shot 68 and described himself as satisfied with that. This is the man who shot 21-under at Valhalla two years ago to rewrite the major championship scoring record. He was genuinely pleased with 68 on Thursday. That one detail communicates more about what Aronimink was doing to people than any number of statistics could.
Seven Men Tied, One Name Above the Rest
The PGA Championship 2026 first round leaderboard ended with seven players knotted at 3-under Scottie Scheffler, Aldrich Potgieter, Stephan Jaeger, Min Woo Lee, Ryo Hisatsune, Martin Kaymer and Alex Smalley. Most of those names will ring bells for serious golf fans. One of them rings bells for everybody.
Scheffler hit 13 of 14 fairways Thursday. On a day when missing fairways at Aronimink meant standing in rough with bad lies and worse angles, hitting 13 of 14 was essentially a cheat code. He made birdies where birdies were available, bogeyed the 14th, birdied the 16th to get it back, signed for 67 and spent about ten minutes answering questions in the kind of measured, calm tone he uses whether he shot 67 or 77. Nothing about his demeanor suggested he thought he’d done anything special. That’s the thing about watching Scheffler at a major. He just operates at a level of even-keeled, relentless competence that somehow never gets boring to witness even when nothing dramatic happens.
Worth noting and this is a strange fact given how dominant he’s been Thursday marked the first time in his career that Scheffler has held at least a share of the lead after opening round at a major. He usually does his damage from behind, tracking people down on the weekend. Last year right here in this same event at Quail Hollow he was tied for 20th after Round 1. Won by three shots. This time he’s decided to just start at the front and make everyone else deal with that.
Good luck to them.
The Kid at the Top Nobody Saw Coming
Then there is Aldrich Potgieter and the thing about him is that he is 21 years old and he hit the golf ball 326 yards on average this season and he walked into Aronimink on Thursday morning and shot 67 like it was a Tuesday practice round and then sat in the clubhouse for a couple of hours as the outright leader of the PGA Championship 2026 while the rest of the world tried to catch him.
Most of them couldn’t.
The easy version of this story is that a big hitter found a course that suits big hitters and went low. But that’s not quite right. Potgieter putted well. He got up and down when he needed to. He didn’t look panicked when shots came up slightly short or when the wind moved something he wasn’t expecting. For a 21-year-old with limited major experience carrying a major leaderboard, there was a composure about how he handled Thursday that suggested something more than just raw talent showing up on a good day.
His 67 was a career low at a major. He is the second youngest player ever to open the PGA Championship that well.
What happens when Sunday comes and the trophy is sitting there and the whole world is watching is a question nobody can answer yet. Thursday was one day. There are three more.
Spieth Climbed and Slipped, McIlroy Just Slipped
Jordan Spieth needs the PGA Championship 2026 to finish his career Grand Slam the same way McIlroy needed the Masters. Thursday gave him a little of both directions in the span of a few holes. He reached 3-under through 15 holes and the gallery around him started buzzing with that particular electricity that follows Spieth when he’s in contention at a major. Then he three-putted from 75 feet on the 16th, made another bogey on the 17th, and walked off at 69 wearing the expression of a man who knows he left something out there.
Still one back. Still very much in this. Three rounds left. Spieth in that position at a major is not someone you cross off.
Jon Rahm posted 69 and said reasonable things. Brooks Koepka also shot 69, hit 15 greens, ranked near the top in approach play, and offered essentially nothing to reporters, which is exactly how Koepka operates at a PGA Championship before he starts climbing leaderboards on the weekend. Three times this man has won this specific event. Seven shots back means something very different when it’s him than when it’s most other people.
Bryson DeChambeau was at 6-over and had to birdie the 18th just to stay there. Patrick Reed played a quiet, clean, bogey-free 68 that barely anyone was discussing Thursday evening. That kind of round at a major has a way of mattering later in the week when the names people were watching have faded.
Three Rounds Left and Nothing Decided
Thirty-three players within two shots. A world No. 1 leading from the front for the first time in his major career. A 21-year-old from South Africa tied alongside him trying to figure out if this week is the one that changes his life. A five-time major champion seven back needing things to go right quickly. A three-time winner of this exact tournament lurking in the middle of the pack saying nothing and hitting greens.
The PGA Championship 2026 is three days from being decided and about as wide open as a major gets after the first round. Aronimink won Thursday. Whether it keeps winning or whether somebody figures it out and runs away from the field is the only question that matters now.
New Jersey Times Is Your Source: The Latest In Politics, Entertainment, Business, Breaking News, And Other News. Please Follow Us On Facebook, Instagram, And Twitter To Receive Instantaneous Updates. Also Do Checkout Our Telegram Channel @Njtdotcom For Latest Updates.
A Wall Street veteran turned investigative journalist, Marcus brings over two decades of financial insight into boardrooms, IPOs, corporate chess games, and economic undercurrents. Known for asking uncomfortable questions in comfortable suits.
A former college-level cricketer and lifelong sports enthusiast, Arun Upadhayay brings the heart of an athlete to the sharp eye of a journalist. With firsthand experience in competitive sports and a deep understanding of team dynamics, Arun covers everything from grassroots tournaments to high-stakes international showdowns. His reporting blends field-level grit with analytical precision, making him a trusted voice for sports fans across New Jersey and beyond.
